Life Imprisonment in Europe: The Prospect of Release between Case Law and Practice

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##

Publicado 16-11-2026
Patricia Carraro Rossetto

Resumen

This article examines life imprisonment through two distinct but intersecting frameworks: the Strasbourg doctrine of reducibility under Article 3 ECHR and the RIMES approach to the harshest penalties, which assesses their orientation towards social inclusion or exclusion. It reconstructs the ECtHR’s case law from Kafkaris and Vinter to Murray, under which a review mechanism must be legally defined and have the practical capacity to assess whether continued detention remains justified in terms of the prisoner’s rehabilitation. The article then analyses RIMES Pool 4 data from nine European jurisdictions, supplemented by recent legal reforms and evidence on review practices and time served. Read together, the two frameworks reveal the limitations of each approach. While RIMES captures sentence duration and irreducibility, it does not consider the quality of review or the rehabilitative opportunities available to prisoners. Strasbourg, by contrast, remains largely procedural and does not convincingly explain how a life sentence can remain compatible with Article 3 when, despite periodic review, it results in decades of continued detention without a genuine prospect of release. A life sentence may therefore remain formally reviewable while operating in practice as a mechanism of permanent exclusion.

Abstract 0 | PDF (English) Downloads 0

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

Sección
Artículos